The Gatsby Hotel

Booked this hotel for a colleague on business trip. Her comments was this is a motel not a hotel, door has a break-in mark, toilet was terrible. Considering we have paid about SGD390 a night, I was totally not expecting this and had to spend extra time to search for other hotels now.

在曼島，紐大附近，性價比還算可以，就是設施老了點

The entire experience at the Gatsby was like being at the Hotel 6. Nothing worked. Had to move rooms 3 times. The over all conditions at the hotel were very Poor. No water offered. Very little water coming out of the shower. The toilet did not work in one room. No place to hang clothes. It just goes on and on.

I had an amazing experience at The Gatsby Hotel, thanks to Peter! He was outstanding—polite, professional, and incredibly efficient. Even when I needed last-minute accommodations, Peter went out of his way to make it happen, even though he didn’t have to. His dedication to excellent service made my stay memorable. Definitely recommend Peter and The Gatsby Hotel!

Room and bathroom are nice, although small. Location is very convenient. Staff lost our luggage, then left it sitting in a hallway for hours unattended. Check-in line over an hour long. Staff walked us into another guest's occupied room, then later unlocked and walked into our room multiple times on multiple days.

Be aware of extra charges! Hotel didn’t have water or coffee, but at check out they charged a fee for holding luggage, water and coffee which they did not have to offer and I didn’t use. They wouldn’t let me check out or leave the hotel without paying a 17 dollars a day facility fee. Tv didn’t work in my room. closest parking was 80 dollars a day the hotel doesn’t have a parking discount like the other hotels in the area. It is cheaper for a reason.

I chose this hotel because of the price and location which is near Mt Sinai Beth Israel hospital. It was a rainy day and the hotel was easy to find. It is located at a corner. You go up a short flight of stairs and reach the small lobby. Front desk ladies are very professional and pleasant . Lobby was bare bones with a small seating area and a stand with some NYC brochures. The room was pretty basic. Doors had a good lock. Our Full Bed was clean , pillows were nice, plump enough and fresh and the white bed sheets were fresh and nicely starched. Air conditioner was newer and worked very well and the bathroom was also very clean. It was a relief to come to a nice cool room with a clean bed after a long day of walking around. However it isn’t a luxury hotel. The paint job on the walls is fresh but is poorly done and one of the black out curtains had one hook missing so the edge was dangling. The closet had an ironing board but no iron . The coffee table had one mug and a couple of packet of instant coffee and cream but no coffee maker. Turns out you have to walk to the front desk and ask for the iron and coffeemaker if you needed one. There was a small lcd TV which was working. There were two clean white bath towels in the bathroom but no hand towels . At least the towels were clean and fresh. The floor , shower curtain and the tub was also newly scrubbed and very clean. Toiletries were sparse . One single bottle of shampoo. They were out of soap bars. I had to go to the front desk and ask for more towels and another bottle of shampoo which they apologized for but gladly provided. So, would I go back again in the future? Yes. For one night it is more than what I need. It is a clean basic bed and shower place to crash into after a long day of walking. If I had to stay more than a night I would bring my own soap and coffee maker next time.

Diabolical · We were supposedly in an upgraded room, the room was in the basement with a skylight at head height Fire escapes were blocked TV – didn't work Complimentary High-Speed Wireless Internet – didn't work Iron and Ironing Board – no iron in room In-Room Coffee Maker – 1 cup in the cupboard no kettle No hairdyer The telephone didn’t work Workspace with In-Room Safe – no safe In addition to the above the paint was peeling including around the electrical sockets, the bath had mould around it and there was only one set of towels which they didn’t resolve.

Stayed here while on a solo trip. It was the best! I’m 22 and just needed a place to lay my things and my head at the end of the night. It was the perfect size room, check-in/check-out was easy, and the staff were all so pleasant. I checked in with Shelly and she was so nice. I will definitely stay here again the next time I visit NY.