The Edgartown Inn, the Edgartown Collection

We had booked here as been wanted to visit the area for years and linked it in with a trip to Boston. Nice drive to catch the ferry and a smooth crossing. Easy drive to the hotel and we arrived early which wasn’t a problem given the time of year but would guess it would have been in high season. Checked in and shown to our room and treated to warm chocolate cookies what a start. Asked for recommendations for places to eat and visit, shown on a detailed map where to eat and even places to visit further afield which we did as beautiful scenery around the island. Rooms are very clean and superbly decorated and presented, it made a change to have a proper shower rather than where we had stayed previous along with some lovely bath products. Simple breakfast but sufficient and some nice touches with different options to eat and teas to drink. Overall a great place to stay and would recommend. One gripe was the cost of parking given the price being paid for the room, and having just seen on trip advisor it’s being promoted as FREE PARKING which is not the case it’s $50 a night additional fees.

Our second stay at the Edgartown Inn and we were even impressed than the last. The property is in an excellent location which makes for easy walkability. The staff (Neusa) were wonderful and the breakfast will undoubtedly exceed your expectations. We did hear another guest complain about the room between rooms / floors - but I would imagine they’re not typical BnB customers. Thanks again for a wonderful stay.

Very nice hotel, centrally located in Edgartown. Nothing seemed to be more than a 5 minute walk away. Neusa and her team kept everything pristine! Rooms are a bit small, but well appointed and there's a lot of common space to relax in. We really appreciated the beach chairs and towels that were available. Would definitely return!

I had a wonderful time at this property last week; four nights. I'm sharing just a few remarks to describe my experience...It was well-appointed and first-class. The breakfast spread exceeded my expectations. Though the space in the room was on the smaller side, the bed was super comfortable with cozy high-quality linens. The staff was amicable and accommodating - everyone was just so darn nice. I especially liked the location which made all the main attractions Chappy Ferry, and restaurants/shopping very walkable. The only downside (for me) is that it is very quiet in the evenings like NO one is sitting outside around the fire pit, I saw no one in the living room lobby, and no one on the front porch so our group felt a bit uncomfortable when we gathered in public areas for our after dinner chats and girlfriend talk time.

2 day stay was terrific. Location to everything in town was perfect. 3-5 min walk to basically everything! Hospitality, Neusa was awesome and so friendly, as well as rooms being clean and comfortable was great. Front porch, Den and breakfast made the stay first rate.

I've rarely been so well in a hotel in recent years. The place is new, very clean, the manager extremely professional, supportive and selfstarted. The hotel is beautifully located. We had a suite and therefore very spacious and with a nice balcony. I cannot talk for the smaller rooms but overall the inn very welcoming and well organised